Henry Kirkland, Jr., Micheal Davis, Janet Wood, Dustin Devine, and Kyle Giblet
Department of Biology,
Southwestern Oklahoma State University, Weatherford, OK 73096
Multiple species of microvertebrates have been found in a Pleistocene deposit of light gray, silty clay. The site from which these specimens were obtained is located 12 km south of Weatherford, SW 1/4, NE 1/4, Sec. 18, T11N, R14W, Washita County, Oklahoma. The deposit is approximately 18 m long and 2.3 m deep. This Pleistocene deposit rests on a bed of Permian red sandstone of the Cloud Chief Formation. There is a gradual color change between the two beds. The matrix is also rich in gastropod shells, as well as other unidentifiable bone and dental fragments.
During three previous excavations, bone samples from the site were radiocarbon dated (Geochron Laboratories , Krueger Enterprises, Inc., 711 Concord Avenue, Cambridge, Massachusetts). These samples yielded an average date of 16,350±190 years before present (YBP). Samples used to date the site include Bison cf. occidentalis, 1990; Equus excelsus, 1991 (1); and Bootherium bombifrons, 1993 (2).
Screenwashing efforts, which began in the summer of 1995, produced several microvertebrate specimens. Some microvertebrate samples have been compared to the collection at Midwestern State University by Dalquest (personal communication). Among the specimens found were four partial upper incisors of Geomys sp., three from the right side and one from the left, and on all four of which the lateral groove is wider than the medial groove; six molars of Neotoma sp; one upper molar of an adult Sylvilagus sp; one upper second incisor of a juvenile Sylvilagus sp; one right mandible, lacking teeth, of Cynomys ludovicianus; and one fragmented arvicoline rodent molar, either Synaptomys australis or Neofiber sp. In addition to these specimens, several unidentified specimens have been excavated, among them a possible Sorex sp. mandible containing three teeth.
Recent screenwashing efforts, beginning in August of 1996, have produced several microvertebrate specimens and fossils belonging to a musk ox, which were identified by comparison of specimens at Midwestern State University. Among the specimens recently excavated are three Thomomys sp, incisors, one complete and two fragments.
The site lies on the border between the present-day ranges of two species, Neotoma micropus and Neotoma floridana. The Neotoma specimens present in our collection at this time include one left M1, one right M2, one right M1, one left M2, and one right mandible fragment containing an M2 and an M3. According to Harris (4), the genus Neotoma in the Southwest can be divided into two major groups based on the development of a dentine tract on the labial surface of M1. N. albigula, N. floridana, and N. micropus generally have tract development to a height of 0.2 mm, while other species typically have a tract of ³0.2 mm. The M3 has a bilophate form, which is typical of most Rancholabrean specimens (5). Measurements of the right M1 were taken using methods described by Harris (4), and include mid-length, 3.49 mm; greatest width of loph 2, 2.03 mm; base of lingual fold 1 to base of fold 2, 0.98 mm; base of lingual fold 2 to anterior face, 2.63 mm; and dentine tract height, 0.01 mm. All the measurements taken are within the observed range of N. floridana (4). On the basis of these measurements, this specimen compares favorably to N. floridana. Other late Pleistocene faunas of similar age occur within a 400-km radius of this site. These include the Kanopolis Local Fauna from Ellsworth County, Kansas (Yarmouth) (6); The Robert Local
Fauna of Meade County, Kansas (11,000±390 YBP) (7); the Tonk Creek Local Fauna (13,270±110 YBP) (8); and the Elm Creek Local Fauna (11,630±90 YBP) (9). Each of these sites has indicated the presence of both Geomys and Thomomys, and all the above, except the Tonk Creek site, indicate T. talpoides.
In the late Pleistocene, the large bovid Bootherium bombifron (including nominal species of Symbos) ranged from Alaska to Texas and Louisiana (10).
At the Washita Local Fauna, we recently excavated a thoracic vertebra, an upper premolar, and a lower right second molar belonging to B. bombifrons. These specimens were found 1.2 m from the top of the clay deposit and 1.1 m from the contact of the clay with the underlying Permian sandstone of the Cloud Chief Formation.
Measurements for the teeth we found are as follows: (a) the lower right second molar length, 75.44 mm, width at top of crown, 40.32 mm, and width at bottom of root 36.95 mm; (b) upper premolar length, 61.88 mm width at top of crown, 23.29 mm width at bottom of root, 19.98 mm.
B. bombifrons apparently lived in a variety of habitats. Preserved food specimens, found in the infundibula of the teeth and in fossilized feces of these animals, indicate they foraged in habitats ranging from coldweather grasslands to woodlands (11).
A long-standing debate has been tentatively settled concerning the taxonomy of Bootherium. Recent comparative studies resulted in placing B. bombifrons in a valid taxon, while designating B. sargenti as the female form of Symbos cavifrons (12). McDonald determined in 1984 that a mummified helmeted musk ox discovered in 1940 was distinctly different from the taxon Ovibos, to which modern musk oxen belong (11).
We thank L. Littlebird for allowing us to remove fossils from her land, Dr. Nicholas Czaplewski for reviewing this manuscript, and Dr. W. W. Dalquest for his help in specimen identification and for his encouragement. We also thank Southwestern Oklahoma State University for providing a Southwestern Faculty Research Grant.
1. Kirkland, H. Jr., Dill, J., and Selfridge, W., Some late pleistocene vertebrates from western Oklahoma. Proc. Okla. Acad. Sci. 71, 55 (1991).
2. Kirkland, H., and Hilliard, J., An extinct pleistocene musk ox from Western Oklahoma. Southwest. Nat. 41, 246-249 (1996).
3. Jones, J., Jr, and Manning, R., Illustrated Key to Skulls Genera of North American Land Mammals. Texas Tech University Press, Lubbock (1992) p. 32.
4. Harris, A.H., Neotoma in the Late Pleistocene of New Mexico and Chihuahua. Special Pub. Carnegie Mus. Nat. Hist. 8, 164-178 (1991).
5. Zakrzewski, R.J., Morphological change in woodrat (Rodentia: Crecitidae) molars, in Morphological Change in Quaternary Mammals of North America (Martin, R.A., and Barnosky, A.D., Eds,), Cambridge University Press, Boston (1993) pp. 392-409.
6. Hibbard, C.W., Zakrzewski, R.J., Eshelman, R.E., Edmund, G., Griggs, C.D., and Griggs, C., Mammals from the Kanopolis Local Fauna, Pleistocene (Yarmouth) of Ellsworth County, Kansas. Museum of Paleontology, Univ. Of Mich. (1978).
7. Schultz, G.E., Four superimposed late-pleistocene vertebrate faunas from southwest Kansas, in Pleistocene Extinctions, The Search for a Cause (Martin, P.S., and Wright, H.E., Jr., Eds.), Yale University Press, New Haven (1967) pp.321-336.
8. Pfau, R.S., A late pleistocene mammal fauna from Stonewall County, Texas. Texas J. Sci. 46, 337-343 (1994).
9. Dalquest, W.W., and Baskin, J.A., Mammals of the Elm Creek Local Fauna, Late Pleistocene of Beaver County, Oklahoma. Am. Midl. Nat. 127, 13-20 (1992).
10. McDonald, J., and Ray, C., The autochthonous North American musk oxen Bootherium, Symbos, and Gidleya (Mammalia: Artiodactyla: Bovidae). Smithsonian Contributions to Paleobiology (1989).
11. Guthrie, R.D., New paleoecological and paleoethological information on the extinct helmeted musk oxen from Alaska. Ann. Zool. Fennici. 28, 175-186 (1992).
12. Nelson, M., and Madsen, J., Occurrence of the musk ox, Symbos cavifrons, from southeastern Idaho and comments on the genus Bootherium. Great Basin Nat. 47, 239-251 (1987).
Received: 1996 Nov 25; Accepted: 1997 Oct 07